New Zealand: Three strikes and no Internet

by Mathew on October 9, 2008 · 8 comments

BoingBoing has a link to a blog post by a New Zealander who sat in on a meeting with New Zealand officials, a meeting ostensibly about getting their input on the country’s proposed copyright legislation, and in particular a so-called “three strikes” rule, which would force Internet service providers to cut off users after warning them twice about copyright infringing behaviour. But as it turns out, the minister wasn’t there to hear any input about why such a rule is either a) wrong, b) stupid or c) wrong — she was there to chew out critics for even suggesting any such thing, and to tell them the law is going through regardless.

She began by strongly expressing her anger that we had complained to her at this stage in the proceedings. None of us, she said, had been to see her before this on this topic. When we protested that we had worked with the Select Committee, which had removed this provision – and balanced it with one which made licence holders liable for false accusations – she said that this was completely inappropriate of the Select Committee, because Cabinet had already decided this was going ahead.

When the group of which Colin Jackson was a part tried to protest that it wasn’t easy to tell for sure whether people were engaging in copyright infringement, the minister said it worked for child pornography; when her critics pointed out that child pornography was a federal crime and copyright infringement was a civil matter, she said that was irrelevant; when they said that removing people’s Internet access was all out of proportion with the alleged offense, she said that New Zealand’s cultural industries were being decimated and something had to be done.

As bad as Canada’s Bill C-61 is — and as Michael Geist continues to point out, it is pretty bad — it’s not nearly as bad as that. Yet.

  • http://wordout.computergeekservices.net jonknight

    wow.
    she sounds like a real… uhhh….
    well, anyway.
    do the people of new zealand have any way to fight this kind of thing?

  • http://www.mathewingram.com/work mathewi

    Apparently not.

  • Pingback: it.gen.nz » If you don’t like the Copyright Act, join up!

  • http://www.experience-dating.com/free-online-dating/free-online-dating/new-zealand.html Alexa Ereanora

    I just want to say that I really love this website and I love this blog and I love New Zealand! I love meeting new people and love
    chatting on blogs and so I have made my own blog, its for people for Christchurch, Wellington and Auckland. It is called 'Experience – New Zealand' and is my first blog, it is unlike this blog but is also a lot of fun – checkout: (http://www.experience-dating.com/free-online-dating/free-online-dating/new-zealand.html)

  • Ricky

    Good:
    People should use there own content. If they can’t create it then they should buy it.
    I don’t raise cows so I buy beef to eat, I don’t take it or steal it I buy it, why should someones writing or art work be any different, if you want it and cant make it buy it. Don’t steal it if you do you loose the tool you used to steal it

    Thumbs up

  • haha

    Ha ha I am not puting my site on this comment good luck catching me! Hack/crack the planet! You think some stubid law is goig to stop us. She is just asking to be ddosed infact who wants to jion my Ddos party on her!!! Get your bot nets ready skiddies. This law shall have no effect we keep on cracking any new shareware open source 4 ever! >_>

  • http://www.exhibeportable.com Pop

    Child pornography has always been a crime in any law. This should be abandoned. This thing should be upon justice.

  • http://www.webroyalty.com/ nick matyas

    Happy new year.2010. this is outstanding comment for posting, thank you.

    webroyalty

Older post:

Newer post: