Did Weezer rip off the Barenaked Ladies?

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail

One of the latest “viral” videos making the rounds of music blogs, Twitter and email lists over the past couple of weeks is the new music video from Weezer, the band behind such hits as Buddy Holly and Beverly Hills. In the clip, singer Rivers Cuomo and the other members of the band appear along with a troupe of Internet “celebrities,” including Gary Brolsma (the Numa Numa guy), the Eepybird guys (Diet Coke and Mentos), Tay Zonday of Chocolate Rain fame and others.

It’s a great idea. At the same time, however, it’s also uncomfortably similar to a music video that Canada’s own Barenaked Ladies did last year, for their song “The Sound of Your Voice.” Although Tay Zonday doesn’t make an appearance, the Numa Numa guy does and so do the Eepybird guys — and so do some other YouTube “stars,” including Matt Harding (of “Where the hell is Matt?”), Tony Huynh (a Canadian YouTuber known as “the Wine Kone”) and Brooks “Brookers” Brodack. As in the Weezer video, some of the stars sing along, although the members of the Ladies don’t recreate their own version of the Diet Coke fountains.

Tribute, coincidence or rip-off? Hard to say. There have been other similar homages to YouTube stars, including an episode of South Park called Canada On Strike that featured the Dramatic Chipmunk character (which is actually a prairie dog) and other YouTube celebrities. And Dan Meth produced an animated tribute to YouTube stars called The Meth Minute, which hit the Internet last year, not long after the Barenaked Ladies video. In any case, it’s clear which of the music videos the crowd really prefers: the Weezer video has more than 6.5 million views after just two weeks, and the Barenaked Ladies video has only 400,000 views after more than a year. How Canadian.

Comments (11)

  1. Gangles wrote::

    A video with bare naked ladies doing poorly on the Internet?

    Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 2:44 pm #
  2. mathewi wrote::

    Ah yes — the ladies are just in the name of the band. I expect the
    video would have done better if they were actually in the video :-)

    Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 2:47 pm #
  3. seemsArtless wrote::

    What is this talk of bare naked ladies? You're based in Toronto, right Matt? I'm calling the mayor, she should step in to make SURE there is no mention of bare naked ladies in Toronto. Not on the blogs, not on stage at city hall, no sir, no way. We can't have that.

    You might be on to something though… it would explain why Weezer started their song “<3 Songs” ( Heart Songs for the noobs ) with a reference to Gordon Lightfoot.

    Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 3:58 pm #
  4. It's cool that Weezer is building on the idea, but it would have been nice if they've given the BNL a shout out if that was part of their inspiration.

    Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 5:35 am #
  5. uh… they'd*

    Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 5:35 am #
  6. mathewi wrote::

    I agree, Blaise. That would have been the cool thing to do.

    Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 8:36 am #
  7. Fagstein wrote::

    The sad truth is that more and more artists are discovering that the best way to get instantly popular on YouTube is to name-drop YouTube stars. That's what lonelygirl15 did in the early stages, and it's what makes these videos so popular. It's also why half the most popular posts on Digg talk about Digg. Internet communities obsess about themselves.

    Dan Meth realized this, which is why he created Internet People to launch his MethMinute series (which goes well beyond that and is actually quite funny).

    Part of it is the bang-for-your-buck ratio of making lists of things. People on the Internet are all about looking at lists. Part of it is the value of the in-joke and pop culture references.

    Eventually, the Internet world will tire of this (if they haven't already), and these videos will lose their charm.

    (I'll also point you to Internet Stars are Viral from about the same time)

    Thursday, June 12, 2008 at 4:18 am #
  8. Church wrote::

    November, '06!

    What do I win?

    Tuesday, June 17, 2008 at 8:36 pm #
  9. mathewi wrote::

    Thanks, Church — you win… a free copy of Weezer's Pork and Beans video, which you can download from YouTube using any one of a number of third-party tools :-)

    Tuesday, June 17, 2008 at 8:48 pm #
  10. diet wrote::

    Hello, for a long time I read your blog, thanks for that that write interesting and
    useful posts.I consider that blogers it is possible to name many journalists.

    Good luck

    Wednesday, January 7, 2009 at 1:50 pm #
  11. diet wrote::

    Hello, for a long time I read your blog, thanks for that that write interesting and
    useful posts.I consider that blogers it is possible to name many journalists.

    Good luck

    Wednesday, January 7, 2009 at 7:50 pm #

Trackbacks/Pingbacks (4)

  1. Viral Weezer Video Not Allowed To Be Viral | Supergeekblog on Tuesday, June 17, 2008 at 4:07 pm

    […] “YouTube stars” and has them reprising their roles in its own video. Others have done similar things, so perhaps it’s not that unique. However, a Techdirt reader named Mike noticed something […]

  2. […] “YouTube stars” and has them reprising their roles in its own video. Others have done similar things, so perhaps it’s not that unique. However, a Techdirt reader named Mike noticed something […]

  3. […] viral video “YouTube stars” and has them reprising their roles in its own video. Others have done similar things, so perhaps it’s not that unique. However, a Techdirt reader named Mike noticed something quite odd […]

  4. […] viral video “YouTube stars” and has them reprising their roles in its own video. Others have done similar things, so perhaps it’s not that unique. However, a Techdirt reader named Mike noticed something quite odd […]