There seems to be a mini-bitchmeme brewing, sparked by VC blogger Fred Wilson’s recent post about Disqus, which is the commenting system that I use on this blog and many others use as well. Why Fred decided to write about Disqus at this point I don’t know — maybe to give the company some free publicity, who knows. In any case, he listed three reasons why he thinks every blogger should use it, including:

  • threaded discussions
  • email replies
  • shared profiles

That was followed relatively quickly by a post from David Risley, in which he said that Disqus seemed “stupid”, primarily because the comments are hosted somewhere else, and therefore they don’t integrate with a blog’s existing comments and if Disqus disappears then those comments are gone for good. Others have noted that Disqus doesn’t support trackbacks either — which I have also mentioned in the past as a drawback of the system, and something I would like to see.

For the record, Daniel Ha of Disqus has promised that both trackbacks and data exportability are coming to Disqus, which would remove a couple of the major complaints about the service. But even with those flaws — or missing features — I am happy to use it, and Fred puts his finger on one big reason why: the ability to respond to comments instantly via email (and also to approve or delete spam via email). As Fred notes, this is huge. And it is handled seamlessly.

Spam — which Don Dodge mentions as an issue in his post — has also been virtually eradicated. I think in the months I’ve had it integrated with my blog, I’ve had Disqus email me twice or maybe three times with a possible spam comment, and in each case I simply replied with “delete” or “approve” and it was handled. Like Fred and Howard, I would encourage anyone looking for a better comment system to give it a try. The benefits far outweigh the drawbacks, as far as I’m concerned. Carlos says he thinks that Google should buy Disqus.

About the author

Mathew 2429 posts

I'm a Toronto-based senior writer with Fortune magazine, and my favorite things to write about are social technology, media and the evolution of online behavior

85 Responses to “My verdict on Disqus: Two thumbs up”
  1. I also give Discus 2 thumbs up – regardless.

    Website Designer

  2. Nice info in your site, I will bookmark your blog ASAP

  3. Adding Disqus is one of the very best things I've done for my blog – http://www.retrovespa.com

  4. Thumbs up for the feature. I will be returning for more insights once in a while. Kudos

  5. I absolutely concur with you. disqus makes life easier managing comments on blogs

  6. Great post! I've bookmarked your blog. Hope we can swap links.

    Why can't I open your rss feed? No post is showing.

    Best Regards!


  7. Not sure exactly how i feel about Disqus yet

  8. I had signed up for an account with them rescently but even I did not find it attractive. Rater I could not find any specific reason to use it.

  9. […] there were a few posts by other bloggers who wrote about their reasons why they like using Disqus but the real discussion didn’t start […]

  10. You won't believe.. For me it is working more efficient and has significantly decreased the amount of spam comments and I can see now.. disqus is good and soon it will become really big..
    divorce lawyer Phoenix

  11. Thanks a lot for sharing

  12. buy viagra

  13. Someone had negative count on my site until recently, when everyone's Clout went up. No idea why, either. I'm confused. Did something change?

  14. This is great info

  15. Kate, who has been dating with the Prince since they met at university eight years ago, is seen as a modern Cinderella with links of london. links of london The romantic relationship between her and her royal beau catches great attention. And she is even expected to be a second Princess Diana. links of london Being similar to Princess Diana, she also has a simple background with an ordinary family, but has extraordinary inherent quality and temperature. links of london However, it has nothing to do with her perfect behavior as Prince's girlfriend since she began to have a relationship with Prince William in 2003. links of london Besides, Kate Middleton's good taste in fashion is also admired by others, being a fashion links of london icon of the new generation of Britain. links of london Wearing only a pair of links of london earrings, her beauty and temperature could not be hidden. links of london But lately an engagement is said around the corner. “A communiqué is in preparation announcing the marriage between William and Miss Katherine Middleton,” the magazine said. links of london links of londonThat's because William will take his girlfriend to Balmoral, the royal retreat in Scotland, for a weekend of shooting with the Queen, reported news of the World on Monday. links of london Although Kate has dinner with the Queen alongside William before, this will be the first time she has lunched alone with the royal grandma. links of london As what was said by the Daily Express: “it is a signal that Kate has been accepted by the Queen as a qualified member of 'the firm'.” links of london links of londonSomething else will be discussed as well, such as what kind of changes will happen to her if she marries the Prince. links of london Do Kate and William mean to each other? I also want to know, so just wait for their future development. links of london

  16. Wow … this is a great blog! Pretty informative as well! That has really helped me a lot in learning some of this stuff that I wasn't familiar with.

    Logo Design

  17. It's very good… no woder it becomes more popular

  18. I bookmarked this already dude great work


  19. I am Very thank full the owner of this blog. Because of this blog is very imformative for me, – Best Penis Enlargement – We list and review the Top Penis Enlargement in market

  20. Disqus is great but you will never have an all round superstar product that fits everyone's needs. I say it offers a lot of things and sure interlinks major blogging platforms great which is (imho) great.

  21. Disqus is great but you will never have an all round superstar product that fits everyone's needs. I say it offers a lot of things and sure interlinks major blogging platforms great which is (imho) great.

  22. Thanks for the hint, I was looking for sth. like that for months :-)

  23. Disqus is the top commenting platform in my opinion. Not only is Facebook Connect integration nice but allowing users to also use their Twitter accounts to leave comments is awesome.

Comments are closed.