Does this mean Larry and Sergey are morons?


Well, last night the Google-YouTube matchup was just a rumour posted by Mike Arrington at TechCrunch, and plenty of people were poo-poohing it — if only because TechCrunch can occasionally be, er… somewhat promotional, if you know what I mean. But now the Wall Street Journal, a publication not known for rushing into print with unsubstantiated rumours, is reporting that the two companies are in talks about an acquisition that could be worth $1.6-billion (U.S.).

The newspaper said that the “discussions are still at a sensitive stage and could well break off,” which is newspaper lingo for “don’t hold it against us if this big scoop turns out not to be true.” And TechCrunch even gets props for breaking the news in the second paragraph of the WSJ story — I bet that page gets framed or laminated and is hanging on Mike’s wall within the hour.

Russell Shaw is saying he told us so, and even my friend Paul Kedrosky thinks the deal makes a lot of sense (although I don’t think GooTube is really a great name, marketing-wise). Jason Calacanis also has a breakdown of why such an acquisition would make “perfect sense.”

So here’s what I’d like to know: what does YouTube’s biggest fan, “Megaphone Mark” Cuban think about this potential deal? I assume it means that Larry Page and Sergey Brin are morons, since Mark seemed to think only an idiot would buy YouTube because of all the copyright liabilities involved.

It’s possible that the talks are not going to result in anything, or that the rumours are coming from YouTube and are an attempt to start a bidding war, as Cynthia Brumfield of IPDemocracy suspects, but if a deal is done I would be very interested to see what Mark’s take on it is after he dissed the company so badly.


Webomatica posted a link in my comments section to a post by Jeff Jarvis from the Online News Association conference (which I had hoped to go to), where Mark Cuban was the keynote speaker. He passed on the news of the WSJ story and the presenter asked Cuban about it, and his response was pretty much what you might expect: Google would be stupid to buy YouTube, and if they did they would wreck it because they would have to remove all the copyrighted stuff. Charlene Li at Forrester has some thoughts about the value of a merger too.

Update 2:

Mark Cuban has posted his thoughts about whether Google would be stupid to buy YouTube. No surprise — he thinks “moronic would be an understatement.” However, he does think it would make sense for Google to do some kind of ad deal with YouTube.

Comments (4)

  1. Webomatica wrote::

    Mark Cuban’s take:

    Friday, October 6, 2006 at 2:41 pm #
  2. Mathew,

    Love the title of this post!

    Cynthia B.

    Friday, October 6, 2006 at 6:54 pm #
  3. Mathew Ingram wrote::

    Thanks, Cynthia :-)

    Friday, October 6, 2006 at 11:30 pm #
  4. John Koetsier wrote::

    If I could only be that stupid. :-)

    Saturday, October 7, 2006 at 3:12 pm #

Trackbacks/Pingbacks (4)

  1. Tailrank - Top posts for Monday October 9, 2006 on Friday, October 6, 2006 at 9:35 am

    Silicon Valley… Search Engine Journal Valleywag InsideGoogle Search Engine Watch Blog ben barren – rss’ing down… ResourceShelf Mark Evans Mathew Ingram:… A VC Smalltalk Tidbits, Industry… TechBlog [IMG]

  2. The Blogging Times » Google, moron on Friday, October 6, 2006 at 5:51 pm

    […] From the blogosphere: LeeAnn Prescott, Techdirt, Silicon Valley Watcher, IP Democracy, Kevin Maney,, Charlene Li’s Blog, Bruce Clay, Inc. Blog,, Business Filter, Good Morning Silicon Valley, B2Day,, Mathew Ingram, Download Squad, Google Watch, CyberNet Technology News, TechBlog, Valleywag, Blogging Stocks, Paul Kedrosky’s …, Open (finds, minds …, Compete Blog, Andy Beal’s Marketing Pilgrim, Beet.TV, SuperGeek, Digital Micro-Markets, Coolfer, Tech Digest, A VC, IP Telephony, VoIP, Broadband, The Tech Report, Search Engine Journal, Lost Remote, Rational rants, Bloggers Blog, The Business Innovation …, Screenwerk, E-consultancy, Howard Lindzon, Mark Evans, I4U News, InsideGoogle, digg, Conversion Rater, VentureBeat, Geek News Central, Valleywag,,, digg Google, Mark Cuban, moron, online video, social network, video, YouTube […]

  3. Adam Sharp SEO Blog on Saturday, October 7, 2006 at 12:17 am

    Google, Youtube, and Mark Cuban…

    So everyone has heard that Mark Cuban thinks Youtube is a horrible buyout candidate for Google. I agree that the bandwidth and copyright issues that Youtube faces are significant. But I still think he’s wrong. Here’s why:
    #1 – Youtube&…

  4. […] Are Larry and Sergey idiots? […]