One question: Is John Dvorak on drugs?

by Mathew on February 16, 2006 · View Comments

I know PC Magazine columnist John Dvorak likes to be controversial, likes to think outside the box – heck, even outside the universe that contains the concept of “boxes” – but his latest column on Apple is a new low (or high, depending on your perspective). I think the editors at PCMag just run his stuff as a kind of gag now. I picture them giggling to themselves, like university students printing some wild-ass piece of gonzo writing in their student paper and hoping the administration doesn’t notice.

Dvorak’s latest brain-wave is that Apple is plotting behind the scenes to dump the Mac OS and run Windows. Makes sense, right? After all, says the columnist, they have moved away from Firewire and are supporting USB now (cue the ominous soundtrack – maybe something from The Exorcist), and the Apple Switch campaign is over and “nobody switched,” he says. That might come as a surprise to some of the hundreds of thousands of people who bought new Macs in the past few quarters, since sales have been rising at a much faster rate than they were before the iPod.

But the biggest weapon in Dvorak’s arsenal is, of course, the switch to using Intel chips. And what kind of chips do PCs that run Windows use? (nudge, nudge) Why Intel, of course (knowing wink). Could it get any more obvious? It certainly could for me. Why on earth would Apple want to run Windows? It wouldn’t make any kind of operating sense whatsoever, since Apple would be giving up the last thing that makes the company unique – apart from some cool hardware. Not only would it piss off the legions of Macolytes who worship Steve Jobs and everything he touches, but it probably wouldn’t win over that many Windows users either.

Not to mention, of course, that Steve Jobs would have to be lobotomized before he would allow something like that to happen, and the odds of that seem slim. Still, I suppose to be fair to Dvorak, the chances aren’t zero. So watch out – if you see Steve Jobs wandering around with a big scar across his forehead where they popped his head open and removed his cerebellum, then the PCMag columnist just might be onto something.

For more on John Dvorak’s growing reality problems, check out Download Squad and MacSlash Phil Sim, the Squashmeister, also has some thoughts – and as usual he takes a refreshingly different tack (although I still think he’s wrong). Not surprisingly, the Unofficial Apple Weblog also has an opinion on Dvorak, and they’ve gone for the “off his meds” angle too. And for the ultimate does of “John Dvorak is nuts,” you will have to go to the obvious URL: dvorakisnuts.org – where you will find a link to this comic strip version of the above incident.

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • email
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • SphereIt
  • StumbleUpon
  • http://www.terralux.org/devblog The Community of Terra Lux

    a small firestorm of controversy. (You can also hear him explain the theory on TWiT 42 (”Dvorak’s Lost It”) – the sound in the background is Leo Laporte beating Dvorak with a sneaker.) So is Dvorak crazy? Oras Mathew Ingram suggests, is he on drugs? Both, perhaps – he’s always been crazy, as far as I’m concerned – crazy, provocative and controversial, now more than ever, and that’s why I’ve been faithfully reading him for

  • http://dvorakisnuts.org/blog/?p=1 John C. Dvorak is Nuts

    is frickin nuts Dvorak… the guy cracks me up. Apple Switching to Windows? ? Another Dvorak Miss Dvorak Misses the Point Dvorak Predicts Apple Will Adopt Windows Dvorak: Apple to Switch to Windows?One question: Is John Dvorak on drugs? John Dvorak is smoking crack John Dvorak smokes Crack John Dvorak is a total assclown

  • http://blogs.siliconvalley.com/gmsv/2006/02/apple_to_ditch_.html Good Morning Silicon Valley

    I’d write: “This would be the most phenomenal turnabout in the history of desktop computing. There’s just one fly in the ointment.” Mission accomplished. The reaction across the blogosphere was summed up in headlines that were gently skeptical: “One question: Is John Dvorak on drugs?”; “Dvorak’s Shootin’ His Mouth Off. Again.”; “Dvorak off his meds: claims Apple switching to Windows”; “John Dvorak is smoking crack”; etc. And Chris Holland over at The Apple Blog responded with an equally well reasoned proposition:

  • http://blog.tokash.org/2006/02/16/no-way-apple-switching-to-windows-would-be-like-palmone-switching-to-oh-wait/ John Tokash » NO WAY! Apple Switching To Windows would be like PalmOne Switching to…. oh, wait…

    [...] Matthew calls our attention to Steve Jobs personality as a reason why this is not likely to happen. I see his point – Jobs does sometimes seem like a zealot. BUT I think that if Steve found a way for MacWindows to be a bigger success than OSX, financially, for Apple, he’d do it. [...]

  • http://squash.wordpress.com/2006/02/17/why-apple-should-offer-windows/ Squash » Blog Archive » Why Apple should offer Windows

    [...] Clearly that won’t happen, as had been widely accepted and explained around the Blogosphere. Gadgetopia – “more preposterous than ever“, Matthew Ingram – “it’s a new low“, MacSlash – “delusional, pot-smoking, half-baked, preposterous, offensive, short-pants-wearing, goose-stepping, lollypop-eating crazy idea” & TechBlog – “whatever professional contrarian John Dvorak is smoking, I want none of it“. Ditching Mac OS X would be like ripping out a major artery. However, Apple should offer Macs running on Windows. And I’ve even got the marketing strategy to make it fly which I’m offering up just because I’m a nice guy. The foundations of Dvorak’s article, I believe, are sound. I firmly believe that Mac OS X that is really what is holding Apple back. Because everything Apple does today gets back to the OS. If I could have bought one of Apple’s beautifully designed machines running Windows chances are I’d have done so by now. I may also have invested in any number of its cool, software products like Garageband, iLife, etc. Those decisions you make based on best of breed products, whereas an OS decision, has always been like changing your religion. It’s a big, life-changing decision. [...]

  • http://www.zoliblog.com Zoli Erdos

    How about Mac OS X – powered Dells one day? :-)

  • Mathew

    Zoli:

    That I could definitely see. Or better yet, one running MacOS and Windows — what the heck, and Linux too :-)

    Mathew

  • http://eric.extremeboredom.net/ FireRabbit
  • http://www.msversus.org veridicus

    “One question: Is John Dvorak on drugs?”

    Short answer: Yes.

    Long answer: Yes, definitely.

  • http://ricksegal.typepad.com/pmv/2006/02/techcrunch5_mor.html The Post Money Value

    Techcrunch5 – Morning Time in the Valley

    While on the west coast for a number of meetings and projects, I was invited to the Techcrunch5 partycelebrating Shel and Roberts book launch as well as testing the limits of Michael Aringtons neighbors. I wasnt aware you could pack 500 people in a house

  • http://www.robhyndman.com/2006/02/25/why-john-c-dvorak-is-wrong-about-apple/ robhyndman.com

    [...] So is Dvorak crazy? Or as Mathew Ingram suggests, is he on drugs? Both, perhaps – he’s always been crazy, as far as I’m concerned – crazy, provocative and controversial, now more than ever, and that’s why I’ve been faithfully reading him for — is it really about 20 years?? Only Dvorak would have the nerve to float this one, and he must have swallowed hard when he did. So, while I think he’s wrong and very possibly pharmaceutically over-medicated, I think it’s also worth spending a few minutes laying out exactly why. [...]

  • http://www.mathewingram.com/work/2006/06/13/dave-winer-calls-john-dvorak-a-liar/ Dave Winer calls John Dvorak a liar » Mathew Ingram: mathewingram.com/work

    [...] I sort of missed this one when it first came along a few days ago, but I happened to come across a video clip of PC Magazine columnist John C. Dvorak from the VloggerCon video-blogger conference, in which the notoriously provocative pundit describes his approach to column-writing. This clip was apparently filmed by Dave Winer, himself a fairly notorious Internet pundit, although of a different sort. It then made the rounds of Slashdot and Digg.com and YouTube and so on. [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Older post:

Newer post: