Why on earth would Google do a PC?

by Mathew on January 4, 2006 · Comments

There’s been a mountain of chatter on the Web about rumours that Google might announce a Google PC – rumours that got a new lease on life from a recent piece in the Los Angeles Times, although they have been around for a while. Those rumours, which have been tracked by CNet, have now been denied by a spokesman for the search giant, and by Wal-Mart, which was supposed to be the company’s partner (along with Wyse Technologies).

It’s a tempting rumour in part because people seem to lust for a strong competitor for Microsoft – and what better competitor than a cash-rich company with a great brand and a market value that is bigger than Coca-Cola and Cisco Systems, and just behind IBM? A little Google cube with a version of Linux on it and some Web-based office software sounds so great, doesn’t it?

The only downside is that it seems like a pretty stupid idea in a lot of ways, as Carlo at TechDirt and John Battelle have both noted. Why should Google bother selling such a system, when it can just avoid all the cost and hassle by distributing software that does the same thing on other people’s computers? I just don’t see the point. Neither does Alec Saunders, (who invokes the ghost of Michael Cowpland).

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • SphereIt
  • StumbleUpon
  • Completely agreed. The rumour has drawn attention purely because it has geekish celebrity all over it. But it makes absolutely no sense at all.

    Which doesn't mean it won't happen. :)
  • Mathew
    True enough, Rob -- it wasn't that long ago I was saying all the same things about how stupid it would be for eBay to pay $2-billion for Skype :-)
  • GOOG PC thing: two words -- sil-ly.

    Skype at $2b thing: two words -- sil-ly.

    - Stuart
  • please stop google...please stop google....
blog comments powered by Disqus

Older post:

Newer post: