Was the NYT wrong to keep quiet? Yes

It’s been more than a week since New York Times reporter David Rohde escaped from his captors in Pakistan, so maybe now is a good time to try and look dispassionately at the massive coverup that prevented news of his kidnapping from being reported for more than six months — a coverup that included not just 40 or so mainstream media outlets but Wikipedia as well, with the personal help of founder Jimmy Wales. Raising such ethical issues seemed somewhat crass in the days following his miraculous escape (although that didn’t stop some observers, including Kelly McBride of the Poynter Institute, from being early critics of the coverup). But those issues deserve to be talked about in more detail.

For the record, I don’t know David Rohde. From all accounts, he is a wonderful friend and colleague, not to mention an excellent reporter who has a great deal of experience working in troubled areas. All of which is — I would argue — completely irrelevant to the issue at hand, namely whether the New York Times and its senior management were right to conceal evidence of his kidnapping, and whether the editors at dozens of other outlets were right to go along with this plan.

I would argue that they were not, and that if anything the coverup has made things harder not just for future kidnapping victims such as Rohde, but for newspapers and other mainstream media outlets as a whole.

(Please read the rest of this post at the Nieman Journalism Lab blog)

14 thoughts on “Was the NYT wrong to keep quiet? Yes

  1. I think this is the dangerous trend we are on that the media only tells people what it wants and attempts to manipulate than allow people to make up their own mines

  2. Hi Mathew, I'm glad you finally got an iPhone. I remember you mentioning you wanted one but had a Blackberry for work. I'm a big fan of the Panorama application… and Bejeweled 2.

  3. [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com> air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com > jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >wholesale t-shirts[/url]

    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com >nike dunk sb[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com >cheap nike air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com > air force one shoes [/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com > air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com > jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com >retro jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >wholesale t-shirts[/url]

  4. [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com> air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com > jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >wholesale t-shirts[/url]

    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com >nike dunk sb[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com >cheap nike air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakergood.com > air force one shoes [/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com > air jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com > jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.sneakersid.com >retro jordan shoes[/url]
    [url= http://www.nike-clubs.com >wholesale t-shirts[/url]

  5. http://www.romanticboots.com/
    Ugg Boots is a famous brand that becomes a cultural phenomenon on a global scale. It has popularized sheepskin boots , slippers, and shoes and now distributes the product worldwide.The most popular ugg Ultra Short, although there are now hundreds of stylesugg classic tall boots sale
    Ultra Short is one of the original traditional look Ugg boots that is designed for durability, comfort, and years of wear. It is made of double-faced sheepskin with suede heel guards. ugg classic tall grey
    The sheepskin fleece lining allows for air circulation that in the summer doesn't heat up your feet and in winter provides insulation against the cold. Shorter height fits great under .Ultra features a removable and replaceable insole. It is easy for on and off. Molded EVA outsole that is light and flexible. It is comfortable and durable for wearing all the year around.A pair of Ugg boots, a matching Ugg handbag or backpack, and a pair of jeans is the perfect outfit for any casual event. With it, you will feel comfortable, look trendy, and be the envy of everyone around you.
    ugg classic tall boots sale

Comments are closed.