Sometimes the news can’t wait

by Mathew on June 23, 2008 · 5 comments

A fascinating story in the New York Times about how NBC tried its best to keep the news of Tim Russert’s death from escaping into the wild so that they could make sure that his family knew about it. But Twitter and Wikipedia beat them to it. According to the Times story, Russert was pronounced dead at the hospital around 2:30 but NBC didn’t mention it on air for over an hour; on Twitter, the first mention I could find through Summize.com came at 2:59. Two minutes later, Russert’s Wikipedia page was updated, by what the newspaper says was an employee of a Web services company that has several NBC affiliates as customers, but then not long afterwards it was reverted to the original.

One interesting note about the event: the employee who first altered the Wikipedia page has apparently been fired. A spokesperson for the company said that “a junior-level employee made updates to the Wikipedia page upon learning of Mr. Russert’s passing, thinking it was public record,” and that the Web services firm had “taken the necessary measures with the employee and apologized to NBC.” Was the person who changed the Wikipedia page committing an act of journalism, or divulging privileged information? I’d vote for the latter, but clearly the company wants to keep NBC as a client.

In any case, as the Times story notes, the lesson is that as long as there is news, people will try to share it. (Note: The NYT story says that NBC tried to hold back the news the same way the legendary King Canute tried to hold back the tide — but Canute (or Knud) didn’t really try to hold back the tide. He pretended to, so as to show the rest of his court that not even kings were as powerful as God or nature).

  • http://blog.meritos.nl Rick

    “Was the person who changed the Wikipedia page committing an act of journalism, or divulging privileged information?”

    How about neither? As far as I can tell, this person was simply engaging in normal 21st century social interaction. Using terms like “publishing”, “journalism” and “news” just obscures the simple reality of it.

  • http://www.mathewingram.com/work mathewi

    I suppose that's true, Rick — except that if something close to
    journalism is involved, there might be more protection for the person
    who got fired for doing it, as opposed to if he was just engaging in
    21st-century social interaction.

  • http://www.mathewingram.com/work mathewi

    I suppose that's true, Rick — except that if something close to
    journalism is involved, there might be more protection for the person
    who got fired for doing it, as opposed to if he was just engaging in
    21st-century social interaction.

  • Pingback: Can The News Be Held Back?

  • Pingback: Wikipedia entry scoops NBC; NBC not happy | Prodigeek

Older post:

Newer post: