Should Twitter be afraid of Facebook?

by Mathew on April 22, 2007 · Comments

The New York Times has a piece about Twitter, including a nice pic of Biz Stone and Jack Dorsey of Obvious Corp. looking pretty pleased with themselves — as they should, considering Twitter’s traffic has apparently tripled in the past month or two since SXSW helped it become the new black. Jason Pontin of MIT’s Technology Review does a nice job of looking at the phenomenon, without trashing it as totally frivolous and irritating.

snipshot_e4xhbsrlhrf.jpgOne thing Jason doesn’t really get into, however, is how Twitter is just part of a continuum of “presence”-related apps, including instant messaging, email and — increasingly — web-based networks such as Facebook. MG Siegler of parislemon has a post on the topic of how Facebook is eating into Twitter’s functionality with some of its recent updates, and I think that’s a good point. As I’ve mentioned before, the way my 17-year-old daughter and her friends use Facebook’s status update is very much like how they change their MSN user name to reflect what they’re doing or how they’re feeling at that moment. They’re not into Twitter, but if you combine how they use Facebook and MSN and text messaging, it makes total sense.

Could Facebook manage to replace the way they (and others) use MSN and text messaging, and take some of the heat away from Twitter? I think it could, if it keeps adding functionality the way it has been to its status update feature. Why not an instant messaging plugin with Twitter-style features, or even a Skype voice-calling add-on? No reason why not.

Share:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Ma.gnolia
  • NewsVine
  • SphereIt
  • StumbleUpon
  • Twitter... 80,000ish members.
    Facebook... 25,000,000ish members.

    Hmmm...
  • I don't think Twitter has anything to worry about. As a facebook user, I use both the status and Jaiku for totally different reasons. Jaiku is more of a way to me receive feedback from likeminded individuals, whereas, my facebook status is simply to let me friends know what I'm doing.

    Also, as far as instant messaging and facebook goes, you should check out my review on Mosoto , which is built on top of Facebook and allows features such as IM, webcam, and the sharing of music (legally), to take place between friends and associates alike.

    http://corvida.ilumine.net/mosoto-web-service-r...
  • I think Twitter has one key spot where it can survive Facebook shifting its weight into their space.

    If Twitter could deliver something that would expand their existing functionality so that it could update MSN, Skype, Facebook etc. status messages as well then they'd actually have something useful on their hands.
  • I don't think that Twitter should be afraid of Facebook because, as you allude to, the use of this sort of "presence-based" application shows that there is a market for it. Competition flooding into this space in various ways only proves this out.

    Just like social news and social networking sites, presence-based apps will sort themselves out based upon tools and functionality, but also by community. Those who end up sticking with Twitter won't be the same kind of people who use Facebook's app, for instance.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Older post:

Newer post: