Maps, satellite photos and Grand Theft Stupid

I’m going to go out on a limb here and disagree with Mike Arrington, who calls the new Microsoft Live Local street-level photo thingamajig a “killer” in one of his typically breathless posts on TechCrunch, in which he says it will help Microsoft’s Live.com continue to “crush” others in the Web 2.0 portal game. I tend to agree with David Galbraith, who suggests quite succinctly that the drive-by map feature is total bollocks and that the Microsoft team have “lost the plot.” I couldn’t have said it better myself.

The interface, as David points out, is ridiculous – a cheesy, video-game style rendering of a car’s cockpit, which you can switch from a regular car to a race car (complete with fire extinguisher). Quirky and fun? Maybe. I would add “stupid and useless” to that list as well though. As one commenter noted on TechCrunch, “not sure what use I would have for something like this.” A fair point. Not to mention, of course, that Amazon’s A9 launched a similar street-level photo feature about six months ago. True, it doesn’t let you “drive” your virtual “car” down the streets, but I actually see that as a positive rather than a negative.

Now if Microsoft could somehow add virtual people to the streets and let you mow them down like in Grand Theft Auto or Carmaggedon – that would be cool. After all, it is called a “street-side drive-by.” But it would still be useless for mapping or finding your way anywhere.

9 thoughts on “Maps, satellite photos and Grand Theft Stupid

  1. Pingback: Charles on… anything that comes along » iPod analysis: are the music wars already over? And will the Mac mini restart the PC wa

  2. Pingback: Planet Apache

  3. frankly speaking. Mike A. is full of BS most of the time. He’s full of hype on every darn tiddly bit of a web2.0 company. And when he can BOGU for any of the Big 3 , he’ll do it. Not sure how live.com is going to crush all the portal game.

    As for the killer App : Edgeio, lets see how he makes out. After all , thats his startup !!

  4. Mathew, I have to disagree with part of your analysis – the useful part. I do agree that the current state of this prototype is cheesy and silly. However, I do believe there is/will be a usefulness to this type of service. Just to be able to scoot down a street and view an intersection, portion of building, business, etc… could be very useful when someone is trying to get a “feel” for the location they are looking for.

    Just today for example, I was going to a seminar in a part of Minneapolis that I’m not totally familiar with – a quick review of the street with this type of service would have saved me 10 minutes. Of couse I went early and got a coffee while looking for the place, so I’ll admit that most of us work around this scenario easily. 🙂

    But…. it is cheesy.
    -Rick

  5. Thanks for the comment, Rick. You’re right, it could be useful — I guess I was just overwhelmed by the cheese 🙂

    Mathew

  6. Pingback: Agylen

  7. Pingback: auto loan even with bad credit. Leilant Snyman

Comments are closed.